Forum
Trades June/July/Deadline
Quote from MrPadre19 on July 30, 2022, 6:43 amQuote from fenn68 on July 30, 2022, 6:31 amI do have this nagging thought that LAA with Trout (best player in MLB for years) … Rendon (mega FA as an elite FA signing) … Otani (super-star) … mega dollars spent on Pujols - Upton … and LAA have not won anything. Do the Padres want to go down that same path with Machado - Tatis - Soto/Otani with big money in underperforming Hosmer and aging Darvish?
As appealing as having super stars is … it does take a team to be the winner.
The Angels just didn’t prioritize pitching and it’s been their downfall.
Preller has done the opposite so I wouldn’t think we’d go there.
He knows you have to have a balanced lineup…..SP/Offense/BP.
Yes adding Soto/Ohtani would take $ away from pitching….but extending Joe is the first step to securing that it doesn’t become a weakness IMO.
Quote from fenn68 on July 30, 2022, 6:31 amI do have this nagging thought that LAA with Trout (best player in MLB for years) … Rendon (mega FA as an elite FA signing) … Otani (super-star) … mega dollars spent on Pujols - Upton … and LAA have not won anything. Do the Padres want to go down that same path with Machado - Tatis - Soto/Otani with big money in underperforming Hosmer and aging Darvish?
As appealing as having super stars is … it does take a team to be the winner.
The Angels just didn’t prioritize pitching and it’s been their downfall.
Preller has done the opposite so I wouldn’t think we’d go there.
He knows you have to have a balanced lineup…..SP/Offense/BP.
Yes adding Soto/Ohtani would take $ away from pitching….but extending Joe is the first step to securing that it doesn’t become a weakness IMO.
Quote from MrPadre19 on July 30, 2022, 6:44 amAnyone else think it’s ironic that Snell/Hosmer/Lamet all looked good a couple days before the trade deadline?
😉
Anyone else think it’s ironic that Snell/Hosmer/Lamet all looked good a couple days before the trade deadline?
😉
Quote from fenn68 on July 30, 2022, 6:47 amWith the injury to Trout (which appears to be chronic) and the perpetual injuries to Rendon taking away productivity from two of the highest payroll pieces for LAA … and a lack luster farm system … not expecting LAA to be a contender for years.
Reports are that Otani wants to play on a winner to get to the World Series … and he will get the money from someone. Doubt Moreno can (or will) lure Otani back with an offer.
I would guess that the LAA minimum for Otani is similar to the minimum for Soto … yes, Soto has one more year but Otani has the mega PR/marketing angle attached (think money for the team) and provides both elite pitching and hitting.
However, neither team has to sell now if they don’t like the offer (their choice) … really puts potential buyers in bind.
With the injury to Trout (which appears to be chronic) and the perpetual injuries to Rendon taking away productivity from two of the highest payroll pieces for LAA … and a lack luster farm system … not expecting LAA to be a contender for years.
Reports are that Otani wants to play on a winner to get to the World Series … and he will get the money from someone. Doubt Moreno can (or will) lure Otani back with an offer.
I would guess that the LAA minimum for Otani is similar to the minimum for Soto … yes, Soto has one more year but Otani has the mega PR/marketing angle attached (think money for the team) and provides both elite pitching and hitting.
However, neither team has to sell now if they don’t like the offer (their choice) … really puts potential buyers in bind.
Quote from Henry Silvestre on July 30, 2022, 6:53 amQuote from fenn68 on July 30, 2022, 6:31 amI do have this nagging thought that LAA with Trout (best player in MLB for years) … Rendon (mega FA as an elite FA signing) … Otani (super-star) … mega dollars spent on Pujols - Upton … and LAA have not won anything. Do the Padres want to go down that same path with Machado - Tatis - Soto/Otani with big money in underperforming Hosmer and aging Darvish?
As appealing as having super stars is … it does take a team to be the winner.
Way I see it both Soto and Otani are relatively young..Soto more so
If we spend Manny + Tatis + (Soto/Ohtani) + Musgrove ...$125
And 1/3 of the roster is made of 1st 3 yr players..Baez/Morejon/Wilson/Gore/Wethers/Batten/Ruiz/Knehr/Castillo
That leaves 13 spots .. and roughly $100mil .. we can 💯 field a perennial winning team
We will also have guys like Lesko/Snelling/Susana and others coming up towards end of 25/ beginning of 26 to give us 1 or 2 cheap controllable SP.. and potential superstar Wood/Merrill/Acosta types and C galore..to keep feeding the 8-9 spots of 3 or less yr players (minimum $$)
Just using our current offseason expected departures and assuming only the players above remain... resign Martinez + Profar + Clev (short term 1 +1/2+1 type deal).. Kim is back $7mil + arb Voit + arb Crone... cut bait with lamet ..bring in a Yu $20mil SP.. ... Suarez opts in $6mil ..That would still leave us $26mil roughly for the final 4 players ...
And we just keep cycling thru.. eventually Kim gets dealt and replaced by a Batten type saving us $6,5... Voit moves on and a power youthful bat Doershing replaces him..and so far so on.. Machado has what 6yrs left? And what if he opts out..But we extend Soto and Tatis ?.. we still have 2 24-25 yr old locked and loaded for a decade... if Rays and Baltimore can do 26 with 80-100mil payrolls or less ..we can do 22 for the same...
Quote from fenn68 on July 30, 2022, 6:31 amI do have this nagging thought that LAA with Trout (best player in MLB for years) … Rendon (mega FA as an elite FA signing) … Otani (super-star) … mega dollars spent on Pujols - Upton … and LAA have not won anything. Do the Padres want to go down that same path with Machado - Tatis - Soto/Otani with big money in underperforming Hosmer and aging Darvish?
As appealing as having super stars is … it does take a team to be the winner.
Way I see it both Soto and Otani are relatively young..Soto more so
If we spend Manny + Tatis + (Soto/Ohtani) + Musgrove ...$125
And 1/3 of the roster is made of 1st 3 yr players..Baez/Morejon/Wilson/Gore/Wethers/Batten/Ruiz/Knehr/Castillo
That leaves 13 spots .. and roughly $100mil .. we can 💯 field a perennial winning team
We will also have guys like Lesko/Snelling/Susana and others coming up towards end of 25/ beginning of 26 to give us 1 or 2 cheap controllable SP.. and potential superstar Wood/Merrill/Acosta types and C galore..to keep feeding the 8-9 spots of 3 or less yr players (minimum $$)
Just using our current offseason expected departures and assuming only the players above remain... resign Martinez + Profar + Clev (short term 1 +1/2+1 type deal).. Kim is back $7mil + arb Voit + arb Crone... cut bait with lamet ..bring in a Yu $20mil SP.. ... Suarez opts in $6mil ..That would still leave us $26mil roughly for the final 4 players ...
And we just keep cycling thru.. eventually Kim gets dealt and replaced by a Batten type saving us $6,5... Voit moves on and a power youthful bat Doershing replaces him..and so far so on.. Machado has what 6yrs left? And what if he opts out..But we extend Soto and Tatis ?.. we still have 2 24-25 yr old locked and loaded for a decade... if Rays and Baltimore can do 26 with 80-100mil payrolls or less ..we can do 22 for the same...
Quote from Henry Silvestre on July 30, 2022, 6:56 amSomeone just twitted that Scott Boras just walked into Petco park...as I was typing...
Someone just twitted that Scott Boras just walked into Petco park...as I was typing...
Quote from fenn68 on July 30, 2022, 7:16 amQuote from Henry Silvestre on July 30, 2022, 6:56 amSomeone just twitted that Scott Boras just walked into Petco park...as I was typing...
At 7 AM!
Boras’ Padre clients are Hosmer, Gore, Manaea, Profar, and Snell … maybe working an extension for one of them? Or just review Gore’s health status?
Of course, could be discussing a long term deal (if given permission by WASH/MLB) to discuss the extension demands for either Soto or Bell …think both are his clients. Padres would offer more/better prospect package if they had the add locked long term .. I guess.
Quote from Henry Silvestre on July 30, 2022, 6:56 amSomeone just twitted that Scott Boras just walked into Petco park...as I was typing...
At 7 AM!
Boras’ Padre clients are Hosmer, Gore, Manaea, Profar, and Snell … maybe working an extension for one of them? Or just review Gore’s health status?
Of course, could be discussing a long term deal (if given permission by WASH/MLB) to discuss the extension demands for either Soto or Bell …think both are his clients. Padres would offer more/better prospect package if they had the add locked long term .. I guess.
Quote from Henry Silvestre on July 30, 2022, 7:30 amQuote from MrPadre19 on July 30, 2022, 6:44 amAnyone else think it’s ironic that Snell/Hosmer/Lamet all looked good a couple days before the trade deadline?
296 .351 .445 .796... Hosmer career splits in July... his best month by far every season 😆 🤣 😂 don't trade me I am hitting!
Quote from MrPadre19 on July 30, 2022, 6:44 amAnyone else think it’s ironic that Snell/Hosmer/Lamet all looked good a couple days before the trade deadline?
296 .351 .445 .796... Hosmer career splits in July... his best month by far every season 😆 🤣 😂 don't trade me I am hitting!
Quote from fenn68 on July 30, 2022, 7:32 amActually Boras was making the rounds at PETCO last night.
One “under the radar” move may be negotiations on Michael Conforto … a FA no longer encumbered by a COMP PICK.
IF healthy, the guy can hit and play decent OF. Padres could get him for “just money” … saving prospects for themselves or other trade needs.
Conforto would fill a 2023 hole in the OF … corner OF since CF is far in his past. Or DH if they move on from Voit. If that happens (or is the discussion) … might signal Soto talks have stalled or the demand has gone beyond what the Padres can (or will) match.
We have been suggesting WASH will drag this out until Tues but always two in the negotiation … and maybe Preller had his own deadline and if no deal … time to move on to other targets. As I said before getting nothing by waiting (and losing) the Soto derby would be a disaster for the Padres and may cost them the playoffs.
Actually Boras was making the rounds at PETCO last night.
One “under the radar” move may be negotiations on Michael Conforto … a FA no longer encumbered by a COMP PICK.
IF healthy, the guy can hit and play decent OF. Padres could get him for “just money” … saving prospects for themselves or other trade needs.
Conforto would fill a 2023 hole in the OF … corner OF since CF is far in his past. Or DH if they move on from Voit. If that happens (or is the discussion) … might signal Soto talks have stalled or the demand has gone beyond what the Padres can (or will) match.
We have been suggesting WASH will drag this out until Tues but always two in the negotiation … and maybe Preller had his own deadline and if no deal … time to move on to other targets. As I said before getting nothing by waiting (and losing) the Soto derby would be a disaster for the Padres and may cost them the playoffs.
Quote from fenn68 on July 30, 2022, 7:35 amQuote from Henry Silvestre on July 30, 2022, 7:30 amQuote from MrPadre19 on July 30, 2022, 6:44 amAnyone else think it’s ironic that Snell/Hosmer/Lamet all looked good a couple days before the trade deadline?
296 .351 .445 .796... Hosmer career splits in July... his best month by far every season
![]()
![]()
don't trade me I am hitting!
Or telling other teams … please trade for me I am hitting and I want to play for a winner on the East Coast?
Quote from Henry Silvestre on July 30, 2022, 7:30 amQuote from MrPadre19 on July 30, 2022, 6:44 amAnyone else think it’s ironic that Snell/Hosmer/Lamet all looked good a couple days before the trade deadline?
296 .351 .445 .796... Hosmer career splits in July... his best month by far every season
![]()
![]()
don't trade me I am hitting!
Or telling other teams … please trade for me I am hitting and I want to play for a winner on the East Coast?
Quote from Henry Silvestre on July 30, 2022, 8:14 amRays Seth Johnson (A+) 98 mph fb former SS sort of late bloomer because of position change and rule V in offseason if left of the 40... might be an interesting return if we acquired a C and traded Nola to the C starved Rays.... Can give us another AA/AAA SP arm (our weakness atm) in the high minors for 2023....
Rays Seth Johnson (A+) 98 mph fb former SS sort of late bloomer because of position change and rule V in offseason if left of the 40... might be an interesting return if we acquired a C and traded Nola to the C starved Rays.... Can give us another AA/AAA SP arm (our weakness atm) in the high minors for 2023....




