Forum
Trades June/July/Deadline
Quote from fenn68 on July 17, 2022, 5:29 amQuote from Henry Silvestre on July 17, 2022, 4:59 amBy the way Spotrac has us at $149 for 23..and only $80 something for 24
2024 with the FA of Darvish and Snell will open up a lot … of course that $80MM is only guaranteed deals … so Machado and Tatis and ????? 24 at league minimum?
Sort of in line with their 2023 … $149 + 20 for CBT benefits, etc gives a $169 base under a $233 threshold .. so $64 under? No idea how Spotrac deals with arb increases and opt outs/in.
If the Padres want to go for Soto … best hope is that Soto does not sign a long term contract until he is a FA (after 2024) when the Padres CBT level will be much lower … could sign him and other needs. Even with his projected ARB in 2023, still a CBT issue with fielding a good full roster.
What is difficult now in sizing a deal is the unknown as to whether the Padres can resign him. He would be expensive in terms of trading prospect for his remaining 2.5 years but if how much more if you know he is yours for 14 years (and have a fixed contract).
Betting WASH is just now testing the waters and serving notice to Soto that he does not hold all the cards … see if Soto modifies his demand. Let that play out since finding another team to construct a mega deal before the trade deadline will be difficult plus some of the mega buyers may more motivated in the off season. WASH is better serviced with the max buyers in the mix … and that should be in the winter.
NYY may make him a priority over Judge (similar money) while BOST may want the younger Soto long term over an aging Martinez. Both could trade some ML pieces more readily after the season to bolster the prospect package.
Even SD could boost a package with Cronenworth and/or Kim betting on Abrams / Rosario to handle 2B.
Bottom line is that WASH in July, 2022 has no motivation to deal Soto unless they get what THEY want.
Quote from Henry Silvestre on July 17, 2022, 4:59 amBy the way Spotrac has us at $149 for 23..and only $80 something for 24
2024 with the FA of Darvish and Snell will open up a lot … of course that $80MM is only guaranteed deals … so Machado and Tatis and ????? 24 at league minimum?
Sort of in line with their 2023 … $149 + 20 for CBT benefits, etc gives a $169 base under a $233 threshold .. so $64 under? No idea how Spotrac deals with arb increases and opt outs/in.
If the Padres want to go for Soto … best hope is that Soto does not sign a long term contract until he is a FA (after 2024) when the Padres CBT level will be much lower … could sign him and other needs. Even with his projected ARB in 2023, still a CBT issue with fielding a good full roster.
What is difficult now in sizing a deal is the unknown as to whether the Padres can resign him. He would be expensive in terms of trading prospect for his remaining 2.5 years but if how much more if you know he is yours for 14 years (and have a fixed contract).
Betting WASH is just now testing the waters and serving notice to Soto that he does not hold all the cards … see if Soto modifies his demand. Let that play out since finding another team to construct a mega deal before the trade deadline will be difficult plus some of the mega buyers may more motivated in the off season. WASH is better serviced with the max buyers in the mix … and that should be in the winter.
NYY may make him a priority over Judge (similar money) while BOST may want the younger Soto long term over an aging Martinez. Both could trade some ML pieces more readily after the season to bolster the prospect package.
Even SD could boost a package with Cronenworth and/or Kim betting on Abrams / Rosario to handle 2B.
Bottom line is that WASH in July, 2022 has no motivation to deal Soto unless they get what THEY want.
Quote from MrPadre19 on July 17, 2022, 5:40 amQuote from fenn68 on July 17, 2022, 3:59 amAt some point the Preller has to see that no team wants Hosmer for anywhere near his contract (maybe not at all give his production deterioration). He is a “sunk cost” and they may just have to bite the bullet to clear him from the roster to get a more productive player in. Options:
1. Find a team that will just take him because of his reputation and team need and pay down his contract as much as needed to get them to make the deal. PTNL type return. Does not help the CBT much but a little does help and Hosmer is off the team.
2. Modify option #1 buy adding some decent prospects to the deal and reduce the buy down opening up more CBT space at the cost of prospects .. buyer is essentially buying the prospects. Sort of depends on the prospects to see if that is a good route.
3. This one is tricky but buyout Hosmer at something less than his remaining contact. Boras as his agent has to have an idea what Hosmer could get on the open market and MIGHT opt for money up front for the shot at FA. More of a future CBT value plus the end of the Hosmer era.
4. The ultimate give up … just DFA him … he would clear waivers and the Padres would be on the hook for his contract no matter where he signs but he will be gone.
5. Light candles and pray for Hosmer taking the opt out at the end of the season.
No chance Hoz opts out at end of this year unless he plays lights out in second half.
Like I said….no chance.
Quote from fenn68 on July 17, 2022, 3:59 amAt some point the Preller has to see that no team wants Hosmer for anywhere near his contract (maybe not at all give his production deterioration). He is a “sunk cost” and they may just have to bite the bullet to clear him from the roster to get a more productive player in. Options:
1. Find a team that will just take him because of his reputation and team need and pay down his contract as much as needed to get them to make the deal. PTNL type return. Does not help the CBT much but a little does help and Hosmer is off the team.
2. Modify option #1 buy adding some decent prospects to the deal and reduce the buy down opening up more CBT space at the cost of prospects .. buyer is essentially buying the prospects. Sort of depends on the prospects to see if that is a good route.
3. This one is tricky but buyout Hosmer at something less than his remaining contact. Boras as his agent has to have an idea what Hosmer could get on the open market and MIGHT opt for money up front for the shot at FA. More of a future CBT value plus the end of the Hosmer era.
4. The ultimate give up … just DFA him … he would clear waivers and the Padres would be on the hook for his contract no matter where he signs but he will be gone.
5. Light candles and pray for Hosmer taking the opt out at the end of the season.
No chance Hoz opts out at end of this year unless he plays lights out in second half.
Like I said….no chance.
Quote from Henry Silvestre on July 17, 2022, 5:42 amAgreed..
Looking at $$ situation with an eye towards 2023.. would Stroman (Cubs) for Hosmer swap + a spec from us.. be something Cubs might do?... not sure how Stroman fits in Chicago..since they aren't contending... if we were to move on from Snell (preferably for prospects) in a separate deal (or 3 way) and get rid of Hosmer in the process.. and end up with Stroman SP (23 +24) + Contreras C in the process might be worth exploring..could use the specs in the Snell trade to juice up offer to Cubs
Agreed..
Looking at $$ situation with an eye towards 2023.. would Stroman (Cubs) for Hosmer swap + a spec from us.. be something Cubs might do?... not sure how Stroman fits in Chicago..since they aren't contending... if we were to move on from Snell (preferably for prospects) in a separate deal (or 3 way) and get rid of Hosmer in the process.. and end up with Stroman SP (23 +24) + Contreras C in the process might be worth exploring..could use the specs in the Snell trade to juice up offer to Cubs
Quote from fenn68 on July 17, 2022, 5:57 amAgree. Did not include the one other option to consider … just keep and live with Hosmer. As bad as he has been performing he still is over 100 in wRC+ and could end up as a part-time 1B/DH post Voit.
He will not opt out and no one will trade for him and take his contract. Sure the Padres could pay almost all the salary (does not help the CBT issue much) or add some very good prospects for a lower buy down but damaging the future … then still have to replace him which requires more money and/or prospect moved in a deal.
Beginning to feel living with him is the best option since moving him may be more detrimental to the future of the team … prospects / replacement cost.
At some point over the next three years the idea of just eating the $13MM and DFA will come up IF he regresses more or alternative emerges.
Agree. Did not include the one other option to consider … just keep and live with Hosmer. As bad as he has been performing he still is over 100 in wRC+ and could end up as a part-time 1B/DH post Voit.
He will not opt out and no one will trade for him and take his contract. Sure the Padres could pay almost all the salary (does not help the CBT issue much) or add some very good prospects for a lower buy down but damaging the future … then still have to replace him which requires more money and/or prospect moved in a deal.
Beginning to feel living with him is the best option since moving him may be more detrimental to the future of the team … prospects / replacement cost.
At some point over the next three years the idea of just eating the $13MM and DFA will come up IF he regresses more or alternative emerges.
Quote from fenn68 on July 17, 2022, 6:14 amQuote from Henry Silvestre on July 17, 2022, 5:42 amAgreed..
Looking at $$ situation with an eye towards 2023.. would Stroman (Cubs) for Hosmer swap + a spec from us.. be something Cubs might do?... not sure how Stroman fits in Chicago..since they aren't contending... if we were to move on from Snell (preferably for prospects) in a separate deal (or 3 way) and get rid of Hosmer in the process.. and end up with Stroman SP (23 +24) + Contreras C in the process might be worth exploring..could use the specs in the Snell trade to juice up offer to Cubs
Cubs view … if Stroman has trade value … couldn’t the Cubs just deal him to a pitching needy team for prospects and not get burdened with 3 years of Hosmer and his contract. Then has $13MM to spend in each of those years to sign a much better FA … maybe half of a Musgrove deal?
IF Stroman is > Snell … he alone would require better prospects to get than Snell would return requiring the Padres to supplement just for that exchange … then add some major prospects to dump Hosmer.
Seems like a no go for the Cubs.
Quote from Henry Silvestre on July 17, 2022, 5:42 amAgreed..
Looking at $$ situation with an eye towards 2023.. would Stroman (Cubs) for Hosmer swap + a spec from us.. be something Cubs might do?... not sure how Stroman fits in Chicago..since they aren't contending... if we were to move on from Snell (preferably for prospects) in a separate deal (or 3 way) and get rid of Hosmer in the process.. and end up with Stroman SP (23 +24) + Contreras C in the process might be worth exploring..could use the specs in the Snell trade to juice up offer to Cubs
Cubs view … if Stroman has trade value … couldn’t the Cubs just deal him to a pitching needy team for prospects and not get burdened with 3 years of Hosmer and his contract. Then has $13MM to spend in each of those years to sign a much better FA … maybe half of a Musgrove deal?
IF Stroman is > Snell … he alone would require better prospects to get than Snell would return requiring the Padres to supplement just for that exchange … then add some major prospects to dump Hosmer.
Seems like a no go for the Cubs.
Quote from Henry Silvestre on July 17, 2022, 7:49 amQuote from fenn68 on July 17, 2022, 6:14 amQuote from Henry Silvestre on July 17, 2022, 5:42 amAgreed..
Looking at $$ situation with an eye towards 2023.. would Stroman (Cubs) for Hosmer swap + a spec from us.. be something Cubs might do?... not sure how Stroman fits in Chicago..since they aren't contending... if we were to move on from Snell (preferably for prospects) in a separate deal (or 3 way) and get rid of Hosmer in the process.. and end up with Stroman SP (23 +24) + Contreras C in the process might be worth exploring..could use the specs in the Snell trade to juice up offer to Cubs
Cubs view … if Stroman has trade value … couldn’t the Cubs just deal him to a pitching needy team for prospects and not get burdened with 3 years of Hosmer and his contract. Then has $13MM to spend in each of those years to sign a much better FA … maybe half of a Musgrove deal?
IF Stroman is > Snell … he alone would require better prospects to get than Snell would return requiring the Padres to supplement just for that exchange … then add some major prospects to dump Hosmer.
Seems like a no go for the Cubs.
At $25 mil per Stroman has - negative- value...sure at $15-$18 he has value... but at $25 he has 💯 negative value...is he solid YES.. but Manea like...no where close to Musgrove ($25mil per) level
Quote from fenn68 on July 17, 2022, 6:14 amQuote from Henry Silvestre on July 17, 2022, 5:42 amAgreed..
Looking at $$ situation with an eye towards 2023.. would Stroman (Cubs) for Hosmer swap + a spec from us.. be something Cubs might do?... not sure how Stroman fits in Chicago..since they aren't contending... if we were to move on from Snell (preferably for prospects) in a separate deal (or 3 way) and get rid of Hosmer in the process.. and end up with Stroman SP (23 +24) + Contreras C in the process might be worth exploring..could use the specs in the Snell trade to juice up offer to Cubs
Cubs view … if Stroman has trade value … couldn’t the Cubs just deal him to a pitching needy team for prospects and not get burdened with 3 years of Hosmer and his contract. Then has $13MM to spend in each of those years to sign a much better FA … maybe half of a Musgrove deal?
IF Stroman is > Snell … he alone would require better prospects to get than Snell would return requiring the Padres to supplement just for that exchange … then add some major prospects to dump Hosmer.
Seems like a no go for the Cubs.
At $25 mil per Stroman has - negative- value...sure at $15-$18 he has value... but at $25 he has 💯 negative value...is he solid YES.. but Manea like...no where close to Musgrove ($25mil per) level
Quote from Henry Silvestre on July 17, 2022, 8:21 amHere is another view on keeping Hosmer..
Lets assume we add Soto (Hos can 1B/DH and at least provide some offense).. it could also allow Pads to give Kowhley (who can play all 3 OF spots + 1B) a shot to play everyday with a barrier of .700 OPS (Hos current level) to be > to keep starting
Without any moves (and only Soto and Musgrove back)
OF - Soto LF/Ruiz CF/Tatis RF
INF 1B Kowhley/2B Crone/SS Kim/3B Manny
C Alfaro
DH- Voit
Bench - Batten/Grishman/Nola/Hosmer
Call me crazy but that's > than current and by a lot...again assuming no adds in offseason
SP 1.Musgrove/2 Yu/3 Snell/4 Gore* (managed to keep Gore in Lieu of Lawson + Wethers going to Washington)/5 Knher
BP
CL- Adams
Pomz/Johnson/Garcia/Suarez/Morejon/Wilson/Castillo
at AAA
Howell OF/INF/ Beaty OF/Rooker OF/Ornelas OF/Hollis INF/Martin 1B/DH/Azocar OF
Pitching at AAA
Jakob/Cosgrove/Baez/Knerr/HILL...others
2023 (after what would be a massive exodus Abrams/Hassell/Wethers/Lawson/Rosario etc..) looks way thin at AAA position players...But BP remains deep maybe even deeper than it is/was in 2022 (even after everyone healthy)
The Bench looks more experienced and the position starters offer some flexibility Tatis (CF/SS)..Kim (2B/3B) Kowhley (OF)..Crone (SS/1B) etc...
Just from an outsider point of view .. AJP could bring in a bee slew of minot league signings (like Mazara in 22) for AAA depth ..could bolster SP by resigning 1 or 2 of Nick Mart/Manea/Clev..or adding inexpensive FA like Davies... Could also bring back Mazara cheapish..who would DH and start in RF vs rhp when Kim sits and Tatis moves to SS...
Anyway that's a payroll < $200mil.. with a lot less holes than our current one..and less swing and miss in our lineup with basically double the power...(Tatis + Soto)
Here is another view on keeping Hosmer..
Lets assume we add Soto (Hos can 1B/DH and at least provide some offense).. it could also allow Pads to give Kowhley (who can play all 3 OF spots + 1B) a shot to play everyday with a barrier of .700 OPS (Hos current level) to be > to keep starting
Without any moves (and only Soto and Musgrove back)
OF - Soto LF/Ruiz CF/Tatis RF
INF 1B Kowhley/2B Crone/SS Kim/3B Manny
C Alfaro
DH- Voit
Bench - Batten/Grishman/Nola/Hosmer
Call me crazy but that's > than current and by a lot...again assuming no adds in offseason
SP 1.Musgrove/2 Yu/3 Snell/4 Gore* (managed to keep Gore in Lieu of Lawson + Wethers going to Washington)/5 Knher
BP
CL- Adams
Pomz/Johnson/Garcia/Suarez/Morejon/Wilson/Castillo
at AAA
Howell OF/INF/ Beaty OF/Rooker OF/Ornelas OF/Hollis INF/Martin 1B/DH/Azocar OF
Pitching at AAA
Jakob/Cosgrove/Baez/Knerr/HILL...others
2023 (after what would be a massive exodus Abrams/Hassell/Wethers/Lawson/Rosario etc..) looks way thin at AAA position players...But BP remains deep maybe even deeper than it is/was in 2022 (even after everyone healthy)
The Bench looks more experienced and the position starters offer some flexibility Tatis (CF/SS)..Kim (2B/3B) Kowhley (OF)..Crone (SS/1B) etc...
Just from an outsider point of view .. AJP could bring in a bee slew of minot league signings (like Mazara in 22) for AAA depth ..could bolster SP by resigning 1 or 2 of Nick Mart/Manea/Clev..or adding inexpensive FA like Davies... Could also bring back Mazara cheapish..who would DH and start in RF vs rhp when Kim sits and Tatis moves to SS...
Anyway that's a payroll < $200mil.. with a lot less holes than our current one..and less swing and miss in our lineup with basically double the power...(Tatis + Soto)
Quote from fenn68 on July 17, 2022, 8:35 amWell Stroman - Snell - Hosmer all have negative value …
IF Padres dealt the full contracts for Snell and Hosmer but added the full contract for Stroman … over the life of the deal the Padres would save about $11MM net over time. In 2023 save about $11MM then in 2024 cost them an additional $8MM ending up with a 2025 savings of $13MM. Plus save maybe $2-3MM this year.
From an AAV standpoint, Padres save a little less than $5MM in 2023 and maybe 1/3rd of that this year.
Cubs would save $9MM (no AAV issue for them) … and the buyer of Snell would have to take on about $20MM (maybe or maybe not an AAV issue). Cubs might bite for the savings since Stroman is just ineffective these days … sort of the Hosmer of the Cubs.
That is a lot of work for a little payoff with maybe the assumption that anyone would take Snell and his contract without the Padres adding prospects or eating some of the contract which negates the net savings. Not opening much space for new adds.
Think I got those number right.
Well Stroman - Snell - Hosmer all have negative value …
IF Padres dealt the full contracts for Snell and Hosmer but added the full contract for Stroman … over the life of the deal the Padres would save about $11MM net over time. In 2023 save about $11MM then in 2024 cost them an additional $8MM ending up with a 2025 savings of $13MM. Plus save maybe $2-3MM this year.
From an AAV standpoint, Padres save a little less than $5MM in 2023 and maybe 1/3rd of that this year.
Cubs would save $9MM (no AAV issue for them) … and the buyer of Snell would have to take on about $20MM (maybe or maybe not an AAV issue). Cubs might bite for the savings since Stroman is just ineffective these days … sort of the Hosmer of the Cubs.
That is a lot of work for a little payoff with maybe the assumption that anyone would take Snell and his contract without the Padres adding prospects or eating some of the contract which negates the net savings. Not opening much space for new adds.
Think I got those number right.
Quote from Jeremy Hill on July 17, 2022, 8:45 amLet's not assume we can add Soto because it's incredibly unlikely.
Let's not assume we can add Soto because it's incredibly unlikely.
Quote from Henry Silvestre on July 17, 2022, 9:28 amQuote from Jeremy Hill on July 17, 2022, 8:45 amLet's not assume we can add Soto because it's incredibly unlikely.
I called the Machado signing in August when he was playing for LAD..he signed with us in Feb/March
Quote me right here right now .. in 17 days Soto will be in LF for your SD Padres..
Quote from Jeremy Hill on July 17, 2022, 8:45 amLet's not assume we can add Soto because it's incredibly unlikely.
I called the Machado signing in August when he was playing for LAD..he signed with us in Feb/March
Quote me right here right now .. in 17 days Soto will be in LF for your SD Padres..




