Forum
2023 Season
Quote from MrPadre19 on April 11, 2023, 5:08 amQuote from 3fingersplit on April 10, 2023, 10:45 amIt’s been fun to watch this team grind with some of the issues they have…catching and not really having a lockdown bullpen yet
looking forward to seeing Tatis on April 20 in Arizona…Melvin said barring any type of setback Tatis should be batting lead off on the 20th and I’ll be there rocking the Padres gear at Chase Field…I just wish I could figure out how to post a picture here on mad friars
Regarding Jake and his swing…he is getting a little bit more of the “straight top hand “ on his swing. Some hitting coaches like the palm up Palm down approach which leads to more fly balls and gravity is not your friend with that approach opposed to driving the ball…Palm to the sky…you hit it high, palm straight and you hit it great
Hopefully our padres continue swinging the hot bats in New York and stick a couple right up the Mets tailpipe starting with tonight ⚾️
Can someone smarter than me,and 3Finger :), tell us how to post a pic on here?
Quote from 3fingersplit on April 10, 2023, 10:45 amIt’s been fun to watch this team grind with some of the issues they have…catching and not really having a lockdown bullpen yet
looking forward to seeing Tatis on April 20 in Arizona…Melvin said barring any type of setback Tatis should be batting lead off on the 20th and I’ll be there rocking the Padres gear at Chase Field…I just wish I could figure out how to post a picture here on mad friars
Regarding Jake and his swing…he is getting a little bit more of the “straight top hand “ on his swing. Some hitting coaches like the palm up Palm down approach which leads to more fly balls and gravity is not your friend with that approach opposed to driving the ball…Palm to the sky…you hit it high, palm straight and you hit it great
Hopefully our padres continue swinging the hot bats in New York and stick a couple right up the Mets tailpipe starting with tonight ⚾️
Can someone smarter than me,and 3Finger :), tell us how to post a pic on here?
Quote from BoosterSD on April 11, 2023, 8:58 amQuote from Jeremy Hill on April 10, 2023, 10:38 pmMartinez clearly wants to be a starter and signed a contract that rewards him for being one. Melvin indicated that he would probably move back to a traditional 5 man rotation after this current stretch of consecutive games. I think that means they'll give him at least 2 more starts to prove he can function effectively as a starter. His first start wasn't bad.
Absolutely, which creates the conundrum. And his lack of consistency as a starter last season was an issue as well. He would have one start, go 7 with great supporting stats like you mentioned. And the next start, he would struggle to get through the line up twice, and tax the bull pen that day.
At some point like last season. I think SD needs to give him the "for the good for the team" speech and move him back to where he was spectacular last season, the bull pen.
Quote from Jeremy Hill on April 10, 2023, 10:38 pmMartinez clearly wants to be a starter and signed a contract that rewards him for being one. Melvin indicated that he would probably move back to a traditional 5 man rotation after this current stretch of consecutive games. I think that means they'll give him at least 2 more starts to prove he can function effectively as a starter. His first start wasn't bad.
Absolutely, which creates the conundrum. And his lack of consistency as a starter last season was an issue as well. He would have one start, go 7 with great supporting stats like you mentioned. And the next start, he would struggle to get through the line up twice, and tax the bull pen that day.
At some point like last season. I think SD needs to give him the "for the good for the team" speech and move him back to where he was spectacular last season, the bull pen.
Quote from fenn68 on April 11, 2023, 10:33 amA lot of moving parts but the call on Martinez should come at the end of the month.
1. April 24th and 28th are off days then one off day each week in May … not really going to need 6 SP if they want to keep the other SP on a regular schedule … not expecting them to want SP to pitch every 7th day considering the days off.
2. Musgrove will be back taking a spot (likely bumping Weathers) …. Leaving Martinez or Lugo as the odd man out of a 5 man rotation.
However, that is a lot of time to incur new injuries and have a better view of Martinez v Lugo. Add a wild card IF Weathers catches fire to hold onto that 5th slot (doubt it but)
Now Martinez seems the odd man out … in 2 weeks?
A lot of moving parts but the call on Martinez should come at the end of the month.
1. April 24th and 28th are off days then one off day each week in May … not really going to need 6 SP if they want to keep the other SP on a regular schedule … not expecting them to want SP to pitch every 7th day considering the days off.
2. Musgrove will be back taking a spot (likely bumping Weathers) …. Leaving Martinez or Lugo as the odd man out of a 5 man rotation.
However, that is a lot of time to incur new injuries and have a better view of Martinez v Lugo. Add a wild card IF Weathers catches fire to hold onto that 5th slot (doubt it but)
Now Martinez seems the odd man out … in 2 weeks?
Quote from Henry Silvestre on April 11, 2023, 1:21 pmQuote from fenn68 on April 11, 2023, 10:33 amA lot of moving parts but the call on Martinez should come at the end of the month.
1. April 24th and 28th are off days then one off day each week in May … not really going to need 6 SP if they want to keep the other SP on a regular schedule … not expecting them to want SP to pitch every 7th day considering the days off.
2. Musgrove will be back taking a spot (likely bumping Weathers) …. Leaving Martinez or Lugo as the odd man out of a 5 man rotation.
However, that is a lot of time to incur new injuries and have a better view of Martinez v Lugo. Add a wild card IF Weathers catches fire to hold onto that 5th slot (doubt it but)
Now Martinez seems the odd man out … in 2 weeks?
Weathers just needs 5 IP 2 runs starts and it would be next to impossible to replace him .. as he would be >Martinez and Snell with that production
Quote from fenn68 on April 11, 2023, 10:33 amA lot of moving parts but the call on Martinez should come at the end of the month.
1. April 24th and 28th are off days then one off day each week in May … not really going to need 6 SP if they want to keep the other SP on a regular schedule … not expecting them to want SP to pitch every 7th day considering the days off.
2. Musgrove will be back taking a spot (likely bumping Weathers) …. Leaving Martinez or Lugo as the odd man out of a 5 man rotation.
However, that is a lot of time to incur new injuries and have a better view of Martinez v Lugo. Add a wild card IF Weathers catches fire to hold onto that 5th slot (doubt it but)
Now Martinez seems the odd man out … in 2 weeks?
Weathers just needs 5 IP 2 runs starts and it would be next to impossible to replace him .. as he would be >Martinez and Snell with that production
Quote from Henry Silvestre on April 11, 2023, 8:54 pmhttps://twitter.com/TooMuchMortons_/status/1645977597065723907?t=bdb79zmgnWuN8DrCAkULbg&s=19
So Campy was OK with the SP .. but didn't put in the work with the BP guys in the past.. appears he is now ..good progress and good sign
Melvin talking about Camp making strides as a catcher pic.twitter.com/bwMgYCYp3g
— Giannis Auntiegotapoodle (@TooMuchMortons_) April 12, 2023
So Campy was OK with the SP .. but didn't put in the work with the BP guys in the past.. appears he is now ..good progress and good sign
Quote from Henry Silvestre on April 13, 2023, 5:29 amI know it's early and all BUT
Campy 4-0 as starting C has allowed 1 SB
Nola 3-6 as starting C has allowed 15 SB
I think is time to give Campy 65% of the starts
I know it's early and all BUT
Campy 4-0 as starting C has allowed 1 SB
Nola 3-6 as starting C has allowed 15 SB
I think is time to give Campy 65% of the starts
Quote from Henry Silvestre on April 13, 2023, 5:46 am.556, .331, .521, .513.... our RF'ers OPS.. Dahl/Dixon/Azocar/Odor....
Tatis can't get here fast enough..
.556, .331, .521, .513.... our RF'ers OPS.. Dahl/Dixon/Azocar/Odor....
Tatis can't get here fast enough..
Quote from Henry Silvestre on April 13, 2023, 9:13 amIn 1113 ABs ... Severino .235 33 134 5 .677
Solid pop.. ok speed... BUT also a cannon for an arm... I mean how much longer do we let Nola C in SD?... The New Rules will only expose him left and right and his Offesnse is aging quickly and not in a good way...
In 1113 ABs ... Severino .235 33 134 5 .677
Solid pop.. ok speed... BUT also a cannon for an arm... I mean how much longer do we let Nola C in SD?... The New Rules will only expose him left and right and his Offesnse is aging quickly and not in a good way...
Quote from fenn68 on April 13, 2023, 9:53 amQuote from Henry Silvestre on April 13, 2023, 9:13 amIn 1113 ABs ... Severino .235 33 134 5 .677
Solid pop.. ok speed... BUT also a cannon for an arm... I mean how much longer do we let Nola C in SD?... The New Rules will only expose him left and right and his Offesnse is aging quickly and not in a good way...
Not supporting a long term commitment to Nola but:
1. His replacement for #1 catcher will be Campusano in the future IF the Padres let him play enough to earn it … Nola (mainly for his work with Darvish) will become the 2nd catcher;
2. The “idea” of a better Severino has to be pushed against the fact that with his ML experience and 29 other teams that could use an upgrade at at least one of the ML catcher slots … Severino ending up signing a minor league contract with the Padres … maybe MLB scouts don’t see the same upside.
Since catchers typically don’t move at the trade deadline to contenders … we will see next winter after the Padres know what they have in Campusano.
Quote from Henry Silvestre on April 13, 2023, 9:13 amIn 1113 ABs ... Severino .235 33 134 5 .677
Solid pop.. ok speed... BUT also a cannon for an arm... I mean how much longer do we let Nola C in SD?... The New Rules will only expose him left and right and his Offesnse is aging quickly and not in a good way...
Not supporting a long term commitment to Nola but:
1. His replacement for #1 catcher will be Campusano in the future IF the Padres let him play enough to earn it … Nola (mainly for his work with Darvish) will become the 2nd catcher;
2. The “idea” of a better Severino has to be pushed against the fact that with his ML experience and 29 other teams that could use an upgrade at at least one of the ML catcher slots … Severino ending up signing a minor league contract with the Padres … maybe MLB scouts don’t see the same upside.
Since catchers typically don’t move at the trade deadline to contenders … we will see next winter after the Padres know what they have in Campusano.




