Forum
NEW CBA NEGOTIATIONS
Quote from fenn68 on September 20, 2026, 6:59 pmHard to game out the optimum strategy for teams / players in signing new deals, opts outs, etc. With the expectation of a work stoppage on Dec 1 (halting all player moves, signings) then the unknown of when the seasons begins (and players sign and get paid). New rules potentially impact completion for players (e.g. salary floor creates more demand then higher salaries, stricter penalties for exceeding CBT may lower top line salaries, limits on deferrals, limits on contract lengths, etc are all on the table. Most will not get approved ... but what does and how does that impact an individual deal ??????????????
All the if/then scenarios might just make teams / players freeze in place during NOV and opt for a mad scramble once the new CBA is signed.
Hard to game out the optimum strategy for teams / players in signing new deals, opts outs, etc. With the expectation of a work stoppage on Dec 1 (halting all player moves, signings) then the unknown of when the seasons begins (and players sign and get paid). New rules potentially impact completion for players (e.g. salary floor creates more demand then higher salaries, stricter penalties for exceeding CBT may lower top line salaries, limits on deferrals, limits on contract lengths, etc are all on the table. Most will not get approved ... but what does and how does that impact an individual deal ??????????????
All the if/then scenarios might just make teams / players freeze in place during NOV and opt for a mad scramble once the new CBA is signed.
Quote from Randy Manese on September 20, 2026, 10:26 pmI agree that 99% or more teams/players currently on the 40 man will likely freeze in place, unless they really want to stay with their current team and the team really wants them at their expected price. For the Padres, I believe this might happen with two of our key players - Adrian Morejon and Ty France. Both have a deep connection with the Padres and San Diego and as long as the new owners present a deal that they judge as fair within their current and future parameters, they will re-sign with San Diego. Expect both to land 3 year deals with easy to reach incentives (post the unpredictable but almost certainly shortened 2027 season).
I agree that 99% or more teams/players currently on the 40 man will likely freeze in place, unless they really want to stay with their current team and the team really wants them at their expected price. For the Padres, I believe this might happen with two of our key players - Adrian Morejon and Ty France. Both have a deep connection with the Padres and San Diego and as long as the new owners present a deal that they judge as fair within their current and future parameters, they will re-sign with San Diego. Expect both to land 3 year deals with easy to reach incentives (post the unpredictable but almost certainly shortened 2027 season).
Quote from fenn68 on September 21, 2026, 3:01 amQuote from Randy Manese on September 20, 2026, 10:26 pmI agree that 99% or more teams/players currently on the 40 man will likely freeze in place, unless they really want to stay with their current team and the team really wants them at their expected price. For the Padres, I believe this might happen with two of our key players - Adrian Morejon and Ty France. Both have a deep connection with the Padres and San Diego and as long as the new owners present a deal that they judge as fair within their current and future parameters, they will re-sign with San Diego. Expect both to land 3 year deals with easy to reach incentives (post the unpredictable but almost certainly shortened 2027 season).
I agree there may be a Padre push to re-sign both Morejon and France before Dec 1 ... I would add buying out King's options with an extension could well be a strategy. I expect all three will be much more expensive than I would have thought 3-4 months ago.
Given the returning controlled players ... and if these three are signed before Dec 1 ... Preller can approach 2027 as he did 2026 with what appears to be low cost "filler" options ... and given all the lower end / mid-range FA needing to sign quickly after the new CBA is approved or not get paid for 2027 he should have a lot to pick from selling in part a "consistent playoff team" to showcase their talents on one year deals to set up their next FA runs.
Side: if the lockout last to July ... 2 week ST ... the regular season ... would expect a number of quick, lower salary, one year deals since teams need players and players (and their wives) need paychecks so not a lot of room to "hold out and negotiate" ... more of a 2o27 of "survival" for both teams and players.
Quote from Randy Manese on September 20, 2026, 10:26 pmI agree that 99% or more teams/players currently on the 40 man will likely freeze in place, unless they really want to stay with their current team and the team really wants them at their expected price. For the Padres, I believe this might happen with two of our key players - Adrian Morejon and Ty France. Both have a deep connection with the Padres and San Diego and as long as the new owners present a deal that they judge as fair within their current and future parameters, they will re-sign with San Diego. Expect both to land 3 year deals with easy to reach incentives (post the unpredictable but almost certainly shortened 2027 season).
I agree there may be a Padre push to re-sign both Morejon and France before Dec 1 ... I would add buying out King's options with an extension could well be a strategy. I expect all three will be much more expensive than I would have thought 3-4 months ago.
Given the returning controlled players ... and if these three are signed before Dec 1 ... Preller can approach 2027 as he did 2026 with what appears to be low cost "filler" options ... and given all the lower end / mid-range FA needing to sign quickly after the new CBA is approved or not get paid for 2027 he should have a lot to pick from selling in part a "consistent playoff team" to showcase their talents on one year deals to set up their next FA runs.
Side: if the lockout last to July ... 2 week ST ... the regular season ... would expect a number of quick, lower salary, one year deals since teams need players and players (and their wives) need paychecks so not a lot of room to "hold out and negotiate" ... more of a 2o27 of "survival" for both teams and players.
Quote from fenn68 on September 21, 2026, 7:30 amDuring the lockout there is no player movement until the new CBA and then potentially a rapid period of FA signings and trades.
Wonder how much the GM will discuss (and agree upon) trades during the lockout ... then announce them as soon as the CBA is approved. If trying to build a roster that hits the season running ... and not waiting to rely on FA that might be able to be signed ... makes some sense.
Preller does not have much to work with ... but with the need for catchers in MLB maybe one of Campusano, Fermin, or Salas could yield a return that could fill in the ML roster blanks as at least an upgrade.
During the lockout there is no player movement until the new CBA and then potentially a rapid period of FA signings and trades.
Wonder how much the GM will discuss (and agree upon) trades during the lockout ... then announce them as soon as the CBA is approved. If trying to build a roster that hits the season running ... and not waiting to rely on FA that might be able to be signed ... makes some sense.
Preller does not have much to work with ... but with the need for catchers in MLB maybe one of Campusano, Fermin, or Salas could yield a return that could fill in the ML roster blanks as at least an upgrade.
Quote from ultratvfan on October 19, 2026, 7:57 amThere is a lot to negotiate in the CBA talks. I hope the season starts on time.
Some of the biggest issues include the salary cap and deferred salaries. As much as I would like to see a salary cap, I would not be upset at a compromise to not have a salary cap if they would do away with the deferred salaries.
There is a proposal to reduce the season from 162 games to 154 games. I don't think 8 games less would be significant. I think they should leave it at 162.
Here is a link to the article on the proposals on the CBA talks:
https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/mlb-cba-negotiations-timeline-2026/
There is a lot to negotiate in the CBA talks. I hope the season starts on time.
Some of the biggest issues include the salary cap and deferred salaries. As much as I would like to see a salary cap, I would not be upset at a compromise to not have a salary cap if they would do away with the deferred salaries.
There is a proposal to reduce the season from 162 games to 154 games. I don't think 8 games less would be significant. I think they should leave it at 162.
Here is a link to the article on the proposals on the CBA talks:
https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/mlb-cba-negotiations-timeline-2026/
Quote from fenn68 on October 20, 2026, 4:07 amI think the shorter schedule was proposed to facilitate expanding the playoffs ... expanding all (or some) to 7 games. More league money from TV and better chance for the "better team" to win.
I give a hard salary cap a zero chance ... not helping the owners' argument with TB and MILW in the World Series. However, might see a tougher set of penalties for violators since the current monetary penalty is not really restrictive.
Deferred money will be interesting ... maybe the "adjust" how they value the contract for Luxury Tax in a way to nullify the "benefit" of deferred money. Even more interesting (but unlikely) is the owners' move to limit length of contracts (5 years?) with some "exception" clauses.
No question a lockout on Dec 1 ... nobody really loses significant money until they start losing regular season games ... and even then a short work stoppage would probably be covered. Pain does not really hit until a month or so. Owners and Union have funds / plans in place to cover early pain ... but as in all negotiations there is a breaking point. At some point the short term pain eclipses the theoretical long term gain.
I think the shorter schedule was proposed to facilitate expanding the playoffs ... expanding all (or some) to 7 games. More league money from TV and better chance for the "better team" to win.
I give a hard salary cap a zero chance ... not helping the owners' argument with TB and MILW in the World Series. However, might see a tougher set of penalties for violators since the current monetary penalty is not really restrictive.
Deferred money will be interesting ... maybe the "adjust" how they value the contract for Luxury Tax in a way to nullify the "benefit" of deferred money. Even more interesting (but unlikely) is the owners' move to limit length of contracts (5 years?) with some "exception" clauses.
No question a lockout on Dec 1 ... nobody really loses significant money until they start losing regular season games ... and even then a short work stoppage would probably be covered. Pain does not really hit until a month or so. Owners and Union have funds / plans in place to cover early pain ... but as in all negotiations there is a breaking point. At some point the short term pain eclipses the theoretical long term gain.




