Forum
2026-2027 Off Season Thread
Quote from Randy Manese on November 14, 2026, 9:40 amI think France will re-sign with the Padres on or before Thanksgiving for a lower base salary than Bauers and certainly for less years than Bauers got. I think it will be incentive laden contract with goals that are not that improbable to reach and, in the end, France will end up where he wants to be and realizes that money is only part of what makes a family happy. Guessing 2 years at 11.5 million base salary that could go to 13 with a club option for a 3rd year at 15 million and a decent buy out clause.
I think France will re-sign with the Padres on or before Thanksgiving for a lower base salary than Bauers and certainly for less years than Bauers got. I think it will be incentive laden contract with goals that are not that improbable to reach and, in the end, France will end up where he wants to be and realizes that money is only part of what makes a family happy. Guessing 2 years at 11.5 million base salary that could go to 13 with a club option for a 3rd year at 15 million and a decent buy out clause.
Quote from WindsorUK on November 15, 2026, 2:35 amThat'd be GREAT to have Ty locked up before the winter of our discontent sets in!
Certainly would give them more leeway with Sheets, and Cronenworth.
And if they plan on moving Nando back to the IF, why in the world would you not put him at SS, and Bogey at 2B? Positions they've both played before, and at this stage of their careers, far more suited ( in that Nando is less likely to try and throw out every runner at 1st regardless of his chances, and Xander's ever decreasing range)
That leaves you with Song as your super-sub back up IF( whilst he may not be the gloveman Jake is, he's half the cost and quite frankly, I think he'll be a better hitter in '27)
That'd be GREAT to have Ty locked up before the winter of our discontent sets in!
Certainly would give them more leeway with Sheets, and Cronenworth.
And if they plan on moving Nando back to the IF, why in the world would you not put him at SS, and Bogey at 2B? Positions they've both played before, and at this stage of their careers, far more suited ( in that Nando is less likely to try and throw out every runner at 1st regardless of his chances, and Xander's ever decreasing range)
That leaves you with Song as your super-sub back up IF( whilst he may not be the gloveman Jake is, he's half the cost and quite frankly, I think he'll be a better hitter in '27)
Quote from fenn68 on November 15, 2026, 7:10 amIF the Padres would like Tatis in the INF ... they must first land a corner OF (actually two if not happy with a Harris/Taylor platoon in LF).
The money for a quality OF such as Sato is in the $20MM range (not much quality below the $10MM range) and that may take the money needed to sign France. Don't forget they want to sign (as a priority) 3-4 quality SP (along with some lower end insurance).
It may be a Sato or France scenario.
A Machado - Bogaerts - Tatis - France INF with Cronenworth backing all 4 slots and DH is good ... a Taylor - Merrill - Harris with Bowen backing all 3 is bad.
Note: some discussion on non-tenders of Sheets (est $6MM) and Sears (est $2-3MM). Maybe re-signed at a lower price point. Some "offset" money?
Since the Japanese players need to be signed before Dec 1 ... that resolution should impact the domestic moves. Padres in on Sato (OF) and Taira (SP). Reasonable chance Preller will know if he is out of the mix well before Dec 1 and make other moves.
IF the Padres would like Tatis in the INF ... they must first land a corner OF (actually two if not happy with a Harris/Taylor platoon in LF).
The money for a quality OF such as Sato is in the $20MM range (not much quality below the $10MM range) and that may take the money needed to sign France. Don't forget they want to sign (as a priority) 3-4 quality SP (along with some lower end insurance).
It may be a Sato or France scenario.
A Machado - Bogaerts - Tatis - France INF with Cronenworth backing all 4 slots and DH is good ... a Taylor - Merrill - Harris with Bowen backing all 3 is bad.
Note: some discussion on non-tenders of Sheets (est $6MM) and Sears (est $2-3MM). Maybe re-signed at a lower price point. Some "offset" money?
Since the Japanese players need to be signed before Dec 1 ... that resolution should impact the domestic moves. Padres in on Sato (OF) and Taira (SP). Reasonable chance Preller will know if he is out of the mix well before Dec 1 and make other moves.
Quote from fenn68 on November 15, 2026, 7:40 amWhat shades my view is that I believe the major money needs to be funding 3-4 SP adds. That will take $60-70MM (AAV) minimum for quality.
Initially gamble on Machado, Tatis, Merrill leading the offense with Bogaerts, Cronenworth, Taylor/Harris, Salas/Fermin/Campusano supplemented by some signing "low cost" support with the likes of Hays, Andujar, Laureano (a lot of FA options).
SP now is only Vasquez (#4-5 type starter) and the high risk (in my mind low probability) return of Musgrove or Darvish. Maybe Musgrove is back as a RP (might set up some trade scenarios of RP). Frankly after two years of rehab and at the end of the season was still having issues with recovery after starts ... not seeing the Musgrove being the elite SP (can't gamble the season on expecting rebound).
Can't really control who will sign but would hope the focus would be on "younger" FA (on longer term deals) or "older" FA on one year deals ... just not "older" FA on longer team deals. Padres have a lot of long term commitments on the books and there is a lot of unknown on the post CBA environment. No matter expect some "grandfathering" of contacts signed before DEC 1 but still some unknown as to the penalty structure for exceeding the luxury tax level in the future (may be draft picks, limits on signing new contracts). Padres will be over (for the 3rd consecutive year) the proposed $258MM level ... so can't ignore the potential of not being able to build for the future if draft picks are forfeited and/or new contracts are limited to 1-2 year deals with $10MM max AAV while over the tax level. It is the unknown that makes all this tricky.
What shades my view is that I believe the major money needs to be funding 3-4 SP adds. That will take $60-70MM (AAV) minimum for quality.
Initially gamble on Machado, Tatis, Merrill leading the offense with Bogaerts, Cronenworth, Taylor/Harris, Salas/Fermin/Campusano supplemented by some signing "low cost" support with the likes of Hays, Andujar, Laureano (a lot of FA options).
SP now is only Vasquez (#4-5 type starter) and the high risk (in my mind low probability) return of Musgrove or Darvish. Maybe Musgrove is back as a RP (might set up some trade scenarios of RP). Frankly after two years of rehab and at the end of the season was still having issues with recovery after starts ... not seeing the Musgrove being the elite SP (can't gamble the season on expecting rebound).
Can't really control who will sign but would hope the focus would be on "younger" FA (on longer term deals) or "older" FA on one year deals ... just not "older" FA on longer team deals. Padres have a lot of long term commitments on the books and there is a lot of unknown on the post CBA environment. No matter expect some "grandfathering" of contacts signed before DEC 1 but still some unknown as to the penalty structure for exceeding the luxury tax level in the future (may be draft picks, limits on signing new contracts). Padres will be over (for the 3rd consecutive year) the proposed $258MM level ... so can't ignore the potential of not being able to build for the future if draft picks are forfeited and/or new contracts are limited to 1-2 year deals with $10MM max AAV while over the tax level. It is the unknown that makes all this tricky.
Quote from fenn68 on November 16, 2026, 9:42 amTomorrow a couple of news items will hit:
- QO need to be accepted or declined ... Padres will find out about Morejon.
- Rosters for Rule 5 protection need to be set. Padres have a lot of open roster spots BUT realistically not much in the way of prospects that need protection. Probably Tucker Musgrove but after that ? The twist from normal is that the new CBA MAY allow players selected in Rule 5 to be sent to the minors and not kept on the 26 man. That may open up teams to do more upside selections. Has to be considered.
Tomorrow a couple of news items will hit:
- QO need to be accepted or declined ... Padres will find out about Morejon.
- Rosters for Rule 5 protection need to be set. Padres have a lot of open roster spots BUT realistically not much in the way of prospects that need protection. Probably Tucker Musgrove but after that ? The twist from normal is that the new CBA MAY allow players selected in Rule 5 to be sent to the minors and not kept on the 26 man. That may open up teams to do more upside selections. Has to be considered.
Quote from fenn68 on November 16, 2026, 11:22 amMany have expected a lot of FA signing before the CBA expires this month but is it possible that a lot of the big money clubs above (or near) the CBT threshold might prefer to make their signings after the new CBA rules are in effect. If so, the better players want that competition for their services and may just hold out until after the CBA to ensure all teams will be bidders.
Maybe a couple of the BIG names might sign to get grandfathered into to current rules (helps player and team) but the next tier and down are not going to get those mega deals and are not THAT desirable ... so?
Padres drag their feet a bit? Focus on the Japanese players who have to be signed by Dec 1?
Note that per Sportac the Padres are 8th highest team payroll for CBT purposes at $215MM ... that is $32MM under the "old" threshold (new is proposed to go up maybe $8MM+/-.
Guessing the Padres have an understanding to what the owners envision as the CBT rules in the new CBA (not necessarily what is being publicly discussed) and IF the penalties are construed as detrimental to the future Padres success ... a reason to be cautious.
Many have expected a lot of FA signing before the CBA expires this month but is it possible that a lot of the big money clubs above (or near) the CBT threshold might prefer to make their signings after the new CBA rules are in effect. If so, the better players want that competition for their services and may just hold out until after the CBA to ensure all teams will be bidders.
Maybe a couple of the BIG names might sign to get grandfathered into to current rules (helps player and team) but the next tier and down are not going to get those mega deals and are not THAT desirable ... so?
Padres drag their feet a bit? Focus on the Japanese players who have to be signed by Dec 1?
Note that per Sportac the Padres are 8th highest team payroll for CBT purposes at $215MM ... that is $32MM under the "old" threshold (new is proposed to go up maybe $8MM+/-.
Guessing the Padres have an understanding to what the owners envision as the CBT rules in the new CBA (not necessarily what is being publicly discussed) and IF the penalties are construed as detrimental to the future Padres success ... a reason to be cautious.
Quote from Jeremy Hill on November 17, 2026, 5:59 amI'm guessing there will be a frenzy of activity towards the end of the month. Teams and agents are going to take negotiations down to the wire. A bunch of big deals happened in the last few days ahead of the last lockout.
I'm guessing there will be a frenzy of activity towards the end of the month. Teams and agents are going to take negotiations down to the wire. A bunch of big deals happened in the last few days ahead of the last lockout.
Quote from BoosterSD on November 17, 2026, 9:59 amCWS have just signed Dustin May, 3 years for $52.5M. So the price for SP is being set. What will that do for Buehler, Pivetta, and King prices??
CWS have just signed Dustin May, 3 years for $52.5M. So the price for SP is being set. What will that do for Buehler, Pivetta, and King prices??
Quote from Jeremy Hill on November 17, 2026, 10:46 amThat May contract seems wild to me. He's never been both healthy and good for more than a few games at a time. 17.5m a year for a guy with less than 3 WAR in 7 seasons. 4 teams have thought that they would be the ones to unlock his potential. They've all failed. It seems like a huge overpay to me.
That May contract seems wild to me. He's never been both healthy and good for more than a few games at a time. 17.5m a year for a guy with less than 3 WAR in 7 seasons. 4 teams have thought that they would be the ones to unlock his potential. They've all failed. It seems like a huge overpay to me.
Quote from MrPadre19 on November 17, 2026, 11:19 amIMO there are two chances we sign Skubal.....slim and none.
BUT,the fact we're even meeting with him (I know AJ is in on everyone) tells me the new owners are good with raising payroll.
I don't think his Agent would have him wasting his time with this meeting if he didn't think they at least "could" sign him.
Which also tells me we can afford to full out the rotation with decent arms if we indeed do not sign Skubal.
I'd rather sign 2-3 solid #3 types than just Skubal....we just too many question marks with the 2-3 guys we even have for the rotation.
Are they healthy enough to give us 15o innings?
Are they good enough to give us 150 innings?
Give me Bubic,Soroka and King.
King/Musgrove/Bubic/Soroka/Vasquez/Hart
or
Skubal/Musgrove/Vasquez/Hart/Brito/Sears
Which one you prefer?
IMO there are two chances we sign Skubal.....slim and none.
BUT,the fact we're even meeting with him (I know AJ is in on everyone) tells me the new owners are good with raising payroll.
I don't think his Agent would have him wasting his time with this meeting if he didn't think they at least "could" sign him.
Which also tells me we can afford to full out the rotation with decent arms if we indeed do not sign Skubal.
I'd rather sign 2-3 solid #3 types than just Skubal....we just too many question marks with the 2-3 guys we even have for the rotation.
Are they healthy enough to give us 15o innings?
Are they good enough to give us 150 innings?
Give me Bubic,Soroka and King.
King/Musgrove/Bubic/Soroka/Vasquez/Hart
or
Skubal/Musgrove/Vasquez/Hart/Brito/Sears
Which one you prefer?




