Site icon MadFriars

Padres Rule 5 Names to Know

By 3:00 pm PST Tuesday, the Padres and every other team in Major League Baseball will need to add any players they want to protect from a potential Rule 5 draft to their 40-player roster.

While it remains unclear if a draft will take place this winter (it didn’t in 2021, the last time the owners locked out players), the Padres have several pitchers among the 36 players who have enough service time to be eligible who are most likely to find themselves on a big league contract before the deadline.

Tucker Musgrove has emerged as a strikeout machine in the Padres organization. (Photo: San Antonio Missions)

Right-handers Tucker Musgrove, recovering from his second elbow surgery in three years, and Francis Peña, who was in consideration last year, are the most likely prospects to be protected. Both relievers rate highly on stuff, even if their results have been inconsistent.

Musgrove, originally drafted as a two-way player as the highest-picked NAIA player in the 2023 class, immediately underwent Tommy John surgery after signing and didn’t make his professional debut until late in 2025. He has only recorded 54.1 total regular season innings since. While he’s been among the game’s best strikeout pitchers when he’s been on the mound, the 24-year-old was slightly delayed to start the 2026 season and had to shut it down in mid-August. When he’s on, he shows a devastating slider that has gotten huge chase rates thus far. He likely will need to dial in the ability to land it for a strike on occasion for it to remain an elite weapon at the big league level, but the raw stuff may be the best in the organization.

The Padres hope Musgrove will be ready to return to action in the spring, but given the uncertainty around the timing of the big league season, a team that selected Musgrove could likely keep him stashed on the injured list for much of the season. The lockout could complicate the Padres’ decision as return-to-competition process for pitchers after nerve transposition is especially inconsistent. If added to the 40-player roster, he will be unable to have any interaction with the team surgeon who performed the procedure or their training staff at just about the point he should be returning to work from the mound.

Francis Peña got back on track in San Antonio. (Photo: San Antonio Missions)

Peña, who turns 26 in January, took a step back in 2026, spending the entire year in San Antonio after pitching all of 2025 in El Paso. The long-limbed righty appeared to find a workable release point midway through the year. Peña likely pitched his way onto the roster with a solid showing in the Arizona Fall League, where he issued only two free passes in 11.1 innings. He works off a solid high-90s sinker that plays well against batters from both sides. Peña threw at least two innings in 18 of his 42 appearances this year, offering some length that could be especially valuable in a big league bullpen in 2027.

Starters Ian Koenig and Eric Yost are the two arms who have starting experience in the upper minors who at least require some consideration for an organization that is wildly lacking in starting depth. Yost, 24, posted a 4.64 ERA for the Missions as he struggled to find the strike zone as consistently as he’ll need to at the highest level. The righty’s best offering is a wipeout curve that he pairs with a fastball that occasionally gets up to 95. Koenig, originally an undrafted free agent who works off a mid-90s sinker, reached El Paso at the end of the year for the first time and was effective across five starts. The 25-year-old tossed 148.1 innings, more than all but three pitchers in minor league baseball this year.

Among position players, Braedon Karpathios has the best mix of tools to potentially reach the big leagues in 2026, though his swing-and-miss is probably too much for drafting teams to take a chance on.

While the Rule 5 draft has become a favorite topic for fans during the offseason, on average, only five players have stuck in the majors each of the last four seasons. Among those picks, White Sox starter Shane Smith and Rays closer Kevin Kelly have been, by a significant margin, the most effective in the big leagues so far.

Players who first were at least 19 when they first signed are first eligible the fourth Rule 5 draft after their signing date, while those whose first contract was signed at 18 or younger get an extra year. That generally means that international signees and high school draft picks from 2022 first became eligible for selection this winter, while college draft picks from the class of 2023 are now in play. The full list of Padres prospects who could be eligible this year is below. We’ll have a full look at the players protected in the minor league phase when and if this year’s draft occurs.

Pitchers: Manuel Castro; Javier Chacon*; Sadrac Franco; Harry Gustin*; Bernard Jose; Ian Koenig; Victor Lizarraga; Ethan Long; Isaiah Lowe; Carson Montgomery; Johan Moreno; Tyler Morgan; Tucker Musgrove; Ryan Och; Cole Paplham; Francis Peña; Zack Qin*; Roel Ramirez; Ethan Routzahn; Gerardo Salas; Braian Salazar*; Fernando Sanchez*; Jackson Smeltz; Will Varmette; Eric Yost

Catchers: Lamar King Jr.; Oswaldo Linares; Anthony Vilar

Infielders: Marcos Castañon; Wyatt Hoffman; Romeo Sanabria; Luis Suisbel; Rosman Verdugo

Outfielders: Jake Cunningham; Braedon Karpathios; Kai Murphy

Exit mobile version